Skip to main content

Table 4 Phylogenetic divergence in host and water microbiomes

From: Community recovery dynamics in yellow perch microbiome after gradual and constant metallic perturbations

 

Time

Groups

Permanova

Multiple test correction

Betadisper

Mrpp

p value

ADONIS

p values B-H

p values

dispersion

p value

MRPP

Ctrl = control regime; CC = concentration is constant; CV = concentration is variable

Gut

T0

All groups

0.052

 

0.079

0.279

CC-Ctrl

0.042 *

0.077

0.048*

0.033 *

CC-CV

0.051

0.077

0.141

0.049 *

Ctrl-CV

0.280*

0.280

0.302

0.234

T3

All groups

0.001**

 

0.367

0.647

CC-Ctrl

0.001**

0.002 **

0.916

0.001***

CC-CV

0.006 **

0.006 **

0.145

0.008 *

Ctrl-CV

0.001***

0.002 **

0.295

0.001 ***

T5

All groups

0.006 *

 

0.217

0.199

CC-Ctrl

0.135

0.135

0.923

0.104

CC-CV

0.005 **

0.012 *

0.084

0.009**

Ctrl-CV

0.008 **

0.012 *

0.130

0.008 **

Skin

T0

All groups

0.016 *

 

0.540

0.500

CC-Ctrl

0.166

0.166

0.649

0.154

CC-CV

0.081

0.122

0.256

0.075

Ctrl-CV

0.026 *

0.078

0.599

0.020 *

T3

All groups

0.008 **

 

0.820

0.580

CC-Ctrl

0.035*

0.049 *

0.619

0.049 *

CC-CV

0.049 *

0.049 *

0.586

0.045 *

Ctrl-CV

0.021*

0.049 *

0.872

0.009 **

T5

All groups

0.001***

 

0.380

0.001 ***

CC-Ctrl

0.011 *

0.011 *

0.749

0.008 **

CC-CV

0.001***

0.002 **

0.307

0.002 **

Ctrl-CV

0.001 ***

0.002 **

0.236

0.001 **

Water

T0

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.656

0.886

CC-Ctrl

0.018 *

0.027 *

1.000

0.009 **

CC-CV

0.002 **

0.006 **

0.291

0.002 **

Ctrl-CV

0.036 *

0.036 *

0.519

0.038 *

T3

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.036 *

0.596

CC-Ctrl

0.002 **

0.002**

0.068

0.002 **

CC-CV

0.001 **

0.002 **

0.020 *

0.001 ***

Ctrl-CV

0.001 ***

0.002 **

0.546

0.001 ***

TR1

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.214

0.108

CC-Ctrl

0.001 ***

0.002 **

0.305

0.002 **

CC-CV

0.001 ***

0.002 **

0.064

0.001 ***

Ctrl-CV

0.007 **

0.007 **

0.653

0.007 **

TR2

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.639

0.381

CC-Ctrl

0.003 **

0.005 **

0.395

0.003 **

CC-CV

0.096

0.096

0.892

0.077

Ctrl-CV

0.001 ***

0.003 **

0.391

0.001 ***

TR3

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.561

0.629

CC-Ctrl

0.001 ***

0.003 **

0.343

0.001 ***

CC-CV

0.003 **

0.005 **

0.536

0.002 **

Ctrl-CV

0.007 **

0.007 **

0.620

0.006 **

TR4

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.498

0.031 *

CC-Ctrl

0.009 **

0.009 **

0.536

0.007 **

CC-CV

0.006 **

0.009 **

0.179

0.009 **

Ctrl-CV

0.004 **

0.009 **

0.578

0.002 **

T5

All groups

0.001 ***

 

0.408

0.027 *

CC-Ctrl

0.002 **

0.002 **

0.331

0.001 **

CC-CV

0.001 ***

0.002 **

0.578

0.003 **

Ctrl-CV

0.002 **

0.002 **

0.438

0.001 **

  1. The phylogenetic distances between OTUs were computed using Gunifrac distance (see “Methods” section). The divergence between treatments and control was assessed using PERMANOVA and the homogeneity for group dispersions (distance from centroid) was evaluated using two multivariate tests, BETADISPER and multi-response permutation procedure (MRRP) of within versus among group dissimilarities. The significance of divergence between groups was measured by applying multiple correction tests with Benjamini-Hochberg BH (p value < 0.05)
  2. p value < = 0.001 : “***”, p value < = 0.01 : “**”, p value < = 0.05 : “*”